Showing posts with label lead-acid. Show all posts
Showing posts with label lead-acid. Show all posts

Monday, February 7, 2011

I'll be back... in 8 hours

Some of my readers have wondered why I have been off the blogosphere in the last few months. The reason is that we brought a house and the move from the apartment to our new place has been a bit of a time sink.

First we went through the four stages of home buying:

Stage 1: What the &%#@ do you mean they accepted our bid? I thought you said we were lowballing?

Stage 2: When you use words like "downpayment", does this involve us giving you a check?

Stage 3: I assume roof's are like batteries? Meaning, when you say it is at the end of its life, there is still 80% left, right?

Stage 4: Keep repeating after me: "Owning is better than renting" and, please, stop asking "why?"!

Then we realized that owning a house also meant owning things like leaf blowers and lawn mowers! So, when I saw that there was a battery-powered lawn mower, I jumped at the chance to push my favorite technology forward.

I was looking forward to using my expertise in batteries to maintain and extend the life of my lawn mower for many years to come.

I was not particularly looking forward to mowing the lawn, but owning a battery-powered mower seemed to make up for that.

Until I realized that the top-rated battery-powered mower uses lead-acid batteries.

Lead-acid!!! really! How old school can one really get.

My first thought: Start a battery company to make Li-ion batteries for lawn mowers.

Then I started thinking about this some more. There must be a catch here. So I started digging into what it was.

Let us do some math: The battery for this lawn mower cost ~$270/kWh. That is one expensive lead-acid battery. Presumably, it is a deep-discharge battery, and so it is better made than a car battery.

And there is probably a significant markup.

Did I mention that the mower was on sale for $300! More like a mark-way-way-up.

Considering a typical Northern California growing cycle, this mower will probably be used ~50 times a year (once a week). These deep-discharge batteries can probably go a few hundred cycles. So I'm thinking 4-5 years easy.

But the bigger problem is going to be the calendar life. Sulfation can kill these cells.

Having said that, the battery is probably going to be at the top-of-charge pretty much through its life (think about it: Mown for 1 hour. Keep it plugged in all week). And remember our rule for lead-acid batteries: Keep them charged. So I think we can expect to get ~3 years from these cells.

Lets do some math for a Li-ion battery. I bought one a few weeks ago. This battery will probably last me 3 years and get me ~300 cycles or so. So it has similar specs to the lead-acid battery.

The Li-ion battery, on the other hand, cost me a whooping $2300/kWh!! No... really. This is what it cost me.

Now... knowing Apple, a new word has to be coined for their level of markup. But still this is one expensive battery.

At this price, a Li-ion lawn-mower-battery would have cost me $800!

All you MBA-types are probably cringing because you all know that cost and price are very different from each other and that the price is dictated by what the market is willing to pay (my wife is an MBA and she gave me this spiel).

Granted. So let us do a cost-differential comparison. This comes out to be ~$50/kWh more expensive for a Li-ion cell. Using this, the cost of a Li-ion battery for this mower would be higher than the lead-acid battery by... the price of lunch!

Not at Chez Panisse. But at the LBNL cafeteria (same quality, but at a much lower price?)

So why not use a Li-ion instead. After all it is almost 5x the energy density.

The mower that I have been talking about in this blog is a push mower. So the battery does not need to drag itself. All it has to do is turn the cutting blade. And space is not a big constraint. The mower's size is dictated by the size of the blade anyway.

So why bother using a new type of battery when you don't really see much of a benefit?

Frankly, although I have not looked at the life-cycle, I'll take a bet that it is probably better for the environment to use a lead-acid battery considering how much of this lead is recycled. In comparison, all you recycle in a Li-ion is the high-value metals in the cathode. The rest, literally, goes down the drain.

Maybe the math will change for a self-propelled mower. Or if the weight of the mower is an issue. But I don't see any reason to jump to using a Li-ion battery for the mower I was looking at. This business plan does not appear to have much legs.

So what did I do? I got the corded version of this mower. It cost me $100 less.

I guess the price that I'm willing to pay to push my favorite technology forward is less than $100!

In my guilt I decided to do my part for the technology by buying a Roomba.

I'm not sure if you guys know about this amazing robotic vacuum. It is pretty interesting to watch. It has sensors that make it slow down when it approaches objects, detect dirt, and prevent it from falling off of stairs.

It is not particularly good at vacuuming. But it feels like it is cleaning the floors and isn't that what's important!

But here is the kicker. The one I have has a Ni-MH battery.

I suppose I should be thankful it is not a lead-acid, but Ni-MH? COME ON!

The last time I checked, the cost of Li-ion and Ni-MH batteries were pretty comparable. And the energy density of Li-ion is 2-3x greater. And remember that in this machine (unlike the mower) the vacuum has to drag its battery along. And space is a big deal. The smaller the footprint, the smaller the space it can vacuum.

So why use a 20th century battery for a 21st century machine? Strange.

A web search revealed that Li-ion Roomba's have apparently died prematurely. If this is the case, then iRobot (the company that makes the Roomba) needs to change battery suppliers.

The vacuum I got goes through 2 rooms and then runs out of juice. It could have finished my house in one charge if it had a Li-ion of the same size. Or you could have a better vacuum on it so that it actually picks up dirt instead of moving it around and still only vacuum 2 rooms. You get the point.

When I first saw this machine, I thought that all the things on Terminator (the movie) were coming true. Jokes apart, it really is a pretty decent robotic cleaner which does indeed find its way around. You can, pretty much, set it and forget it.

But then I realized that we had nothing to worry from the machines as long as battery technology evolves the way it has been in the past.

When Arnold Schwarzenegger's character said "I'll be back" on T2, he (it) actually meant "I'm running out of battery and I need to go find an outlet and charge for 8 h. I will then come back to look for you for the 1/2 hour my battery lasts. Wish me luck".

So much for the machines taking over.

If you constantly complain about how batteries are not evolving fast, did you ever consider for the second that maybe we are out to save the world in our own way?

Venkat

Sunday, November 7, 2010

This week in sulfation

First off, I have to apologize to all 7 of my regular readers for not making a post in a while. I have been busy and hence the hiatus. Between watching reruns of Curb your Enthusiasm, election ads, and the Giants world series games, I need more time in a day. But all good things have to come to an end. I hope to resume regular postings starting now.


This week, I was rudely reminded that just because you know how batteries work does not mean that you can deal with a battery problem. But first some background.


Subaru's are excellent cars and I would highly recommend buying one. They are well made, they run great, and they hardly give you any problems (touch wood). But Subaru's also have small quirks that can be bewildering and a bit infuriating. Like not having a remote trunk opener or having only 3 wiper speeds. Or having this one light that does not turn off when the ignition is off and is so hidden that you can't tell that its on in the first place.


The light serves no real purpose, except to make sure to keep the battery industry thriving. Long story short, "someone" left that light on on Sunday (and I'm not saying who).


A bit more background: My car is 7 years old. My battery is (or was as of yesterday, but I'm getting ahead of myself) the original battery.


Monday morning at 7 AM I get to my car to start driving to San Francisco Intl. to catch a flight to Washington DC to be at the center of the action during election day (Tuesday). I was using a meeting on energy storage for grid applications (think storing solar and wind electricity) as an excuse to get someone else to pay for the trip. I was going to be gone all week.


Except my grand plan was crumbling because my car appeared to have a dead battery. I quickly realized what had happened.


When professionals are thrown into a crisis, they do not think, they react. Think Jason Bourne coming across an assassin or Neo coming across Agent Smith (in the Matrix).


Just so there is no confusion: I consider myself to be a professional.


In a matter of seconds the pieces started to fall into place in my brain without any real thinking. I knew my battery was probably pretty sulfated (and corroded with lots of shedding, for that matter). I opened the hood, took one look at the battery and I could literally see the sulfation on the plates (through the grime that covered the hard polypropylene battery shell). I knew that if I jumped the car right away I had a chance of saving the battery. I also knew that if I left it in the discharged state all week, I would probably sulfate it more and maybe end up killing the battery altogether.


To remind you, when you discharge a lead-acid battery you form lead sulfate. Lead sulfate is pretty insulating. But it has a bit of solubility in the electrolyte (sulfuric acid). This leads to some Pb2+ ions in solution. When you charge, these Pb2+ ions allow you to get back to the charged compound. As you react the Pb2+, more lead sulfate dissolves.


Sulfation is a process by which the lead sulfate starts to agglomerate together to form large crystals. This leads to a loss of surface area. What this means is that you don't have enough area for the electrolyte to dissolve the lead sulfate to form Pb2+. So charging the battery gets harder. Sulfation takes a while; maybe in the order or days. Not hours.


Sulfation is reversible. But you have to charge the battery very very (very) slowly so that you slowly dissolve the large crystals of lead sulfate to Pb2+ and convert them back to the charged state. But, who has the patience to wait all week to charge a battery!


What this means is that discharged lead-acid batteries are bad news. You need to avoid them like the plague.


So the path was clear: Get a jump start, drive the car for the next hour and half to SFO and hope that the battery gets its life back. Like I said, a professional does not think. He/she reacts.


But a professional also recognizes his/her limitations. In my case, my limitation was that I was really cheap and had not invested in jumper cables or AAA insurance. A professional also typically has no real friends. I knew that none of my "friends" would be willing to stop by to give me a jump at 7 AM.


So I reacted to this problem by taking BART (i.e., public transport) to the airport.


I dont know if you guys encounter this, but sometimes when you have something on your mind it seems like the whole world is starting to think about the same thing. So here I was thinking about sulfation of lead-acid batteries and at this conference on grid storage, there was all this talk about the UltraBattery (this is a trade name) as a means of preventing sulfation. There were actually two talks completely dedicated to it.


I spoke about this advance a little while ago. The concept is to add some carbon into the negative plate when you make the electrodes. Everything else stays exactly the same. But for some magical reason the sulfation decreases significantly.


The talks were showing data where the battery was being cycled a little bit (like a Prius battery does) where the battery without the carbon tanks after a few hundred cycles but the one with the carbon works much better (thousands of cycles). Apparently, the carbon solves the sulfation issue.


There is a variant of this idea which involves connecting the negative plate in parallel to an electrode made of activated carbon. Activated carbon by itself is used to store energy in the double layer (i.e., a double layer capacitor). So essentially you are connecting a battery electrode in parallel to a capacitor electrode in both these configurations.


What was amazing was that they really had no idea why this was happening (although its been a few years since this first came out). DOE is actually funding a project to try to get to the bottom of this advance. Its sad but true- there is a fundamental change in a 150 year old technology but we have no idea why this change occurred.


Some things in life are really hard to reconcile (e.g., is there a God? why does EVERYBODY make more money than Scientists?) but this problem is not in the same class. I believe that this lack of understanding comes down to limited funding for research combined with the "herding" of research topics.


Lead-acid batteries are cheap. The one that I ultimately replaced my car with cost me $165/Kwh. Assuming I got ripped off (is that even an assumption for things car related?) it stresses the point that these batteries are cheap. Adding a few percent of activated carbon to the paste is not going to break the bank. All through the conference I kept wondering why lead-acid's are not being made with a bit of activate carbon to ensure that sulfation is not a problem.


As an aside, the cheapest battery we know of is the lead-acid battery. For grid applications, the thought is that we need batteries that cost less than $100/kWh. Something pretty radical has to happen for us to make these cost numbers. Making batteries the way we have made them in the past will not allow us to get there. But this is for another post.


So would adding a bit of carbon result in the battery lasting the life of the car (say 15 years)? The company that is commercializing this says it could last 7 or maybe 15. Meaning: they have no idea! Problem with not knowing why something works- there is no way to predict how long it will work. Moreover, the data they show is based on Prius-like cycling. My car does not have the same cycling profile. Unless we understand what is going on, we have no way to knowing how changing conditions will change performance.


In time, this data will show up and we will know if we will can make a better lead-acid car battery. But wouldn't it be better if we understood what was going on?


Truth be told, I'm not at all convinced that my battery was sulfated and could have been saved with a timely jump start. It lasted 7 years! That's a long time. Plates corrode and they shed. Maybe I ought not to expect more from my energy storage devices.


But being able control failure modes in batteries is crucial in ensuring that we can move to electric drive. And they will be crucial if we ever want to store the electricity from the sun. Solar panels last 25 years; do you really want to change your batteries every 5 or 7 years?


But to control the failure, you first need to understand them. And in many cases, we don't quite have life of batteries pinned down. They change with chemistry, multiple failure modes occur at the same time, and in some newer chemistries we just haven't had the time to collect the data to see what the failure mode is.


So we have clues and hypothesis for failure, but we can't quite predict failure rates with cycling conditions. There is no cycle/calendar life simulator for batteries.


Actually that is not true. There are many many life simulation tools for batteries. But none of them actually work!


To me this incident highlights the importance of fundamental research to understand real-world problems. There is quite a bit of fundamental research; and there is no dearth of real world-problems. What we don't do enough of is linking the two (The Program at Berkeley is unique in that its the only one that does this in the whole field of batteries).


It also highlights the fact that I really ought to stop being so cheap, spend some money, and get jumper cables.


Venkat


Monday, September 6, 2010

A Brief History of Batteries- Part 2

Last week I posted on the need to understand the history of battery development and how this will influence the future of batteries.  We conclude today with Part 2 of this series. 

Chapter 3:  If it is sparingly soluble, then lets talk. 

The lead acid battery is the first rechargeable battery ever made.  Its endurance over 150 years is a testimony to its robustness (or to the fact that battery researchers can’t seem to find anything better even after 150 years.  It is all a point of view!). 

The lead acid battery undergoes what is called dissolution-precipitation.  This is the mechanism by which charge/discharge occurs in the battery.  Basically, you dissolve the compound in solution and then it precipitates out.

The behavior of the lead-acid battery is remarkably similar to that of the zinc electrode in a Zn-manganese oxide alkaline battery or for that matter to the lithium thionyl chloride battery.

But if the lithium thionyl chloride is not a rechargeable battery and the zinc-manganese oxide is not a rechargeable battery, then why is the lead acid a rechargeable battery? 

This is because the lead sulfate is soluble in sulfuric acid (which is the electrolyte) unlike the lithium chloride.  But it’s not as soluble as the zinc oxide in potassium hydroxide.  

Its solubility is not too much, nor too little.  It’s just right!  It’s referred to as a sparingly soluble salt. 

This feature of having sparing solubility is critical in making a battery that undergoes dissolution-precipitation recharge. 

This occurs because the reactants and the products are right next to each other.  This means that when you go in reverse, there is a high probability that things go back to the same place where they came from.  Not having something move around is a great way to prevent shape change.

Once you understand that solubility is key you begin to understand the decades that were spent on trying to change the solubility of zinc oxide in electrolyte using various techniques.  And you begin to start thinking about ways to encapsulate the zinc.  And you begin to wonder if you should never let the zinc precipitate as zinc oxide and if you should just keep it as zincate by, say, flowing it. 

All these perfectly valid ideas start to make a lot of sense.  What you can’t answer is if these ideas will succeed in solving the fundamental problem with the zinc electrode. 

But we should remember that in general, the lead-acid is not the greatest battery in the world when it comes to recharging.  Think sulfation.   Remember the blog post on battery rules where I Haiku-ed my way to better battery life?  Remember that sulfation occurs in the discharged state. 

The reason for this is also fundamentally connected to this dissolution-precipitation mechanism.  On the one hand, this mechanism allows you to make a good rechargeable battery, on the other hand, it also causes it to die in time. 

Moral of this story:   If you want good rechargebility, dissolution-precipitation is not a good idea, although we may be able to live with it.    

Chapter 4:  And you thought electroplating was easy.

Electroplating has been a gift that has been giving for decades.  Probably the last big development was the via-hole plating of copper for making semiconductor chip interconnects. 

In general, plating something uniformly is not easy, but it’s not an unsolvable problem either.  We do have a lot of smoothly plated stuff all over the place. 

This is until you try plating lithium (and a few other metals, including zinc).   Plating lithium is sort of important because this would be the charging reaction if you want to make your watch battery a rechargeable battery or if you want to make a Li-sulfur or Li-air battery rechargeable. 

People spent much of the 2-3 decades of the last century trying to make a rechargeable lithium (watch) battery.  The last time I check, I was asked to buy a new watch battery and not try to recharge it. 

This is because, in the case of lithium, the plating results in dendrites and lead to shorting of the battery. 

The reason for this starts with surface inhomogeneities that lead to nucleation of the deposition process in one spot, after which ohmic and transport effects lead to further amplification of this inhomogeneity.

That complicated paragraph is tying to tell you that it plates out like a needle sticking out of the electrode.  The needle can puncture through the separator and short to the cathode.  As I keep mentioning in these blog posts, shorting a battery is not a good idea.  Really, it is not.

Same problem happens in the zinc electrode.  Zinc wants to plate out as a dendrite instead of a smooth surface.  Same reasons as above. 

Every electrochemist that learns of this issue immediately thinks of 10 things to try that could solve the problem.   Turns out all 10 ideas probably don’t work.

There have been, literarily, thousands of studies on trying to solve this issue.  The most promising appears to be using a separator that is hard and prevents the dendrite from growing. 

But as of today, we do not have a method to prevent lithium dendrites at room temperature and give us good power capability.  It’s a problem that is still around. 

The moral of this story:  If your battery requires you to plate out a metal, it is probably going to be an issue achieving good rechargebility. 

And if you want to make a rechargeable Li-air or Li-S electrode, getting the lithium to recharge is, I’m pretty confident, a pre-requisite. 

Epilogue:  Rules to live by. 

So how do we make a rechargeable Li-S and Li-air (or zinc-air) battery?

If I knew that I would not be writing blog posts!

But we need to beat three things that history has taught us: 

1.     Avoid electrodes that require a plating reaction. 
2.     If you have a product that is highly soluble, you are in trouble
3.     If you don’t have any solubility, its worse

One can avoid all this by finding systems where no structural changes happen.  Thus were born systems like Ni-MH, Li-ion, and Ni-hydrogen.  These systems have their own problems, but atleast we are starting with something that has certain inherent advantage.   I will elaborate on these problems in the very near future when I delve into the present-day developments in batteries. 

But suffice to say, if you want to make the battery of the future, then you have to beat the three issues listed above. 

Along the way, you may make the batteries of the past also work.  

Venkat

Monday, August 30, 2010

A Brief History of Batteries- Part 1


When I was around 13 years old I remember learning about primary batteries in school.   This was about the time when I had also encounter lead-acid batteries and had realized that the car starter battery is being charged periodically.  I began to wonder why some batteries could not be recharged while other could.  Thus began my fascination with batteries. 

The above story is probably not true.  But it’s etched in my memory probably because it provides me with a romanticized notion of why I work on batteries today.  In reality, I was probably contemplating something more useful like “what is the point of learning math?”.   

Nonetheless, the question posed is an interesting one in that if we want to understand how to make a rechargeable battery that lasts a long time over many cycles, we first need to understand why some batteries do not recharge.  

The development of batteries is deeply rooted in this understanding (atleast one hopes it is and that it isn’t a series of accidents!).  Many of the ideas that people are proposing today for better batteries are in some ways trying to beat the fundamental limitations that prevent recharging of these primary batteries. 

If you don’t want to make the mistakes of the past, you better understand the past.  This post is an attempt to do just that. 

The topic I’m discussing is technical.  I’ve tried my best to make it accessible.  In doing so, I lose some technical accuracy; but this is the price of making it understandable.    

This blog post is written in the style of a novel.  The story of rechargeability can be written in a very linear fashion which steps through time to illustrate the rules one after another.  But this would make it easy to understand. Where is the fun in that!

So, I’ve borrowed a page from Quentin Tarantino’s movie Pulp Fiction and scrambled the narrative.  Each storyline is distinct, and they are all interrelated.  If the stories were arranged chronologically as the systems developed we would go Chapter 3, 2, 4, 1, Prologue, Epilogue.  I personally think the scrambled version reads better. 

This week I will start with the Prologue and Chapters 1 and 2.  Next week I will finish with Chapters 3 and 4 and the Epilogue. 

Fortunately, these stories are easier to follow when compared to Pulp Fiction.

And there is no swearing or violence. 


Prologue:  Do I smell sulfur in the air?  

There has been a lot of interest over the last few years on two systems that have been around for years.  These batteries are sold as going “beyond lithium-ion”.   These systems use lithium metal as the negative electrode and air (rather, the oxygen in the air) or sulfur as the positive electrode.  Some consider these systems to the Holy Grail of battery research. 

The promise that these battery chemistries hold is enormous.  In the case of lithium-air, the gravimetric energy is an order of magnitude higher than today’s batteries.  Think cars that can drive 500+ miles, cell phones that actually last all day, laptops that can last the complete transatlantic flight...  The volumetric energy is not that great, but hey, let us focus on the positives, shall we.

But there is a hitch (there always is).

In the case of lithium-air, it turns out that recharging lithium metal is a problem.  And the oxygen in the air reacts to form a compound that is basically pretty insoluble. 

In the case of sulfur, the lithium metal continues to be a problem.  And the sulfur electrode undergoes a series of reactions giving products that are either highly soluble, or insoluble.  All the products are a real pain to deal with and history shows us that dealing with them may not be for the faint of heart. 

If we are to succeed in getting these batteries to work, we first need to understand why similar concepts have failed in the past. 


Chapter 1:  A business plan that can’t fail- Take cheese; make milk.
  
You may remember my previous blog post where I alluded to the lithium thionyl chloride battery.  

This chemistry is used for missile applications.  In this battery lithium dissolves from Li metal on the negative electrode and the resulting lithium ions combine with thionly chloride (SOCl2) to form lithium chloride (LiCl) in the positive electrode. 

This is the process that occurs on discharge and it works pretty well.  If you want to recharge this battery, you will need to take the lithium chloride and convert is into thionyl chloride.   This is where the problem occurs. 

Lithium chloride is an insoluble solid.  Once you form it, it pretty much sits around and starts clogging up the whole cell.  Converting lithium chloride back to thionyl chloride is like trying to find a Quentin Tarantino movie with no violence- its not hard to find; its impossible to find!

Think of this as taking a pot full of hot milk and adding lemon juice to it.  The milk curdles and you get cheese.  There is pretty much no way to get back to milk and lemon juice from cheese (as far as I know).  Same story with lithium chloride. 

If, on the other hand, the lithium chloride were soluble in the electrolyte and dissociated in the solution, one can think of trying to recharge the system.  However, because lithium chloride is not soluble, there is no way to recharge the battery. 

Moral of the story:  If the product of your reaction leads to an insoluble product, in some batteries, recharging can be a problem.

The caveat “in some batteries”, is kind of important, but that is not for this post.    

Something similar happens in the lithium carbon monofluoride system (Li-CFx).  In this system, much like the thionly chloride system above, the lithium dissolves and reacts with the carbon monofluoride to form lithium fluoride and carbon; both solids.  Trying to go back to the starting chemicals by reacting the lithium fluoride with the carbon is pretty much impossible.  It’s the cheese to milk problem. 

So solubility is something we ought to be paying attention to when it comes to recharging. 

But what if the product of the reaction is highly soluble (think salt in water)?  This must be the best thing possible for recharging, would it not? 

Turns out that this is not true either.  This would be the story of the zinc electrode.  As in the zinc-manganese oxide alkaline battery (the Energizer-bunny battery).


Chapter 2:  If only the Dead Sea weren’t as salty. 

The alkaline battery is actually a rechargeable battery.  It’s just that it is not a very good one.  Some of you may remember that there were rechargeable alkaline batteries in the market that promised a few cycles. These all appear to be gone from the market.  I guess no one wants to carry around a charger. 

The positive electrode (MnO2) in these batteries can recharge thousands of times if you are careful to avoid certain phases.  I personally believe that this chemistry is worth revisiting. 

It’s the zinc electrode that is the problem.  The reaction involves zinc electrochemically reacting and forming a complex called zincate.  As the concentration of zincate increases, it precipitates out as zinc oxide.   Think of this as adding salt into water.  You can only add so much salt before the solution gets saturated and any more salt you add stays as crystals. 

This is the simple version. 

The whole reaction scheme is actually pretty complicated.  Turns out that five other reactions can happen in this battery depending on various conditions.  Some years ago, I was involved in modeling of the zinc-MnO2 battery and it is by far the most complicated battery chemistry there is.  Lithium batteries are so much easier to understand with compared to this system. 

The zinc oxide has pretty high solubility in the electrolyte (potassium hydroxide). What this means is that zinc oxide easily goes into solution to form zincate in the electrolyte.  One would think this is great for recharging and it is.  But it turns out that when you try to deposit the zinc from the zincate, it does not deposit in the same place where it dissolved. 

This leads to the structure of the zinc electrode changing continuously as you charge and discharge the battery repeatedly.  This is referred to as shape change.  Shape change leads to the zinc depositing as a solid mass in the one part of the electrode.  And this solid mass is hard to react.  Slowly, as the solid mass gets more pronounced, the zinc electrode fades. 

Reduce the solubility of zinc oxide and you can decrease the shape change and increase the cycle life. There is some wonderful data that shows that. This is like somehow making salt less soluble in water.  Turns out that in reality this approach also kills the power of the battery and so this is not a real solution. 

The reason why the shape change happens is a bit complicated, and probably not relevant at this stage.   What does matter is that, in some batteries, very high solubility can be a bad thing and can decrease the ability to recharge. 

Moral of the story:  High solubility may not necessarily be a good thing for recharging.

So we have a problem.  Neither no solubility nor high solubility appears to be a good idea.  So how do we make a rechargeable battery?

We shall look at that in the next chapter.  Next week. 

Now… isn’t that a nice tease!  Stay tuned. 

Venkat  

Sunday, April 11, 2010

Lithium-lithium everywhere...

Over the last 15 years the whole battery community has slowly starting looking at one single system: the lithium battery. I remember going to an Electrochemical Society meeting in 1996 to present a paper on Ni-MH batteries. My talk was scheduled for Monday AM (read prime time). By 1997, I was down to Wednesday, and by 1999, I was talking Friday PM with 3 people in the room (yours faithfully, the presenter before me, and the one after me. Even the session chair was missing!). If one was looking to read the signs, this was it.


This week I was talking to someone who was interested in electrochemical capacitors (more on this later) and he asked if all the research was only on lithium batteries or do we do anything else? I had to admit that there was very little that goes on other than lithium. Since that conversation, I've been thinking about the effectiveness of having all our eggs in the lithium basket and wondering if this is a good thing.


First off, I should note that when it comes to batteries, lithium has a lot more energy per weight or volume compared to the other batteries we have been looking at in the past. Its got 4-5 times the energy per mass as a lead-acid battery and 2-3 times that for a Ni-MH battery. There is still a lot more that can be done with this chemistry and so there is a reason for us to obsess about this. When it comes to batteries for a plug-in or an electric car, we need all the energy we can get and working on lithium does make a lot of sense.


But does this mean that there are no advances that can be made in other energy-storage technologies? And even if we do make advances in these other areas, does it really have any impact in the world? Let's look at the second question first.


Remember that we have argued that batteries for plug-in and EVs are going to very expensive and that they may not last very long either. Its far from given that we will indeed be driving in these battery-powered cars. We may not be cost competitive with gasoline for a while, and we may end up seeing that these cars as a niche market. Maybe hydrogen will take off as a carrier and batteries as a primary energy source will not be the future. The future is far from clear, but it is possible that we may end up finding out that hybrid vehicles (like your out-of-control Prius) may be the most common vehicle on the road for a decade. But even your Prius is not as popular as it could be because its expensive.


But when it comes to hybrids, its not energy that is critical, but the power. Many batteries, including the lead-acid and the Ni-MH batteries have the power capability to satisfy the requirements for a hybrid. The cheapest battery we know of is the lead-acid battery. So if we can get the power with a lead-acid battery and if its the cheapest battery we know of, why don't we use this for hybrids?


Remember the post on battery rules where we asked you to "keep you lead-acid charged"? You may also remember that this was important because if the lead-acid is ever discharged, it sulfates and causes capacity loss. In a hybrid, the battery is always sitting partially discharged. This is important because if you hit the brakes, you need to be able to accept the juice in your battery. Hybrid batteries operate around 50% state of charge because of this. Try using a lead-acid at a partially discharged state and you will have a dead battery long before the new car smell fades.


But something strange happened to the lead-acid battery when the rest of us were obsessing over the lithium battery. The companies working on this started using activated carbon in their negative plates. Lo and behold!, these companies started seeing much better cycling with this new concept. Some companies are doing variations of this by replacing the negative electrode with activated carbon so that its a hybrid between a battery and a capacitor. Companies doing this are promising all the cycle life you need at 1/4 the cost of the Li-ion for hybrids! The catch: they don't yet know if the batteries will last 10 years. So they can get the cycle life, but its not clear they can get the calendar life.


But that is not the point I want to make. What amazes me is that someone can take a 150 year old technology and show that they can make it better by solving a particular problem that stops it from being used for an application. I'll take a bet that 90% of the researchers in the field of batteries don't know of this advancement (all right, that may be a bit of an overstatement, but you get the point). I had worked on a mathematical model for a lead-acid battery a few years ago where I had included some features in the model that make it easy to address this advance. A person in the lead-acid industry had sent me a mail when these findings started coming out asking if I was doing anything to address these new findings. I had to (sadly) tell him that although this was interesting, I had no way of doing anything because all my funding is in the area of lithium batteries.


But what if we find out that the new lead-acid batteries do have a calendar life issue. Should we leave it to companies to figure this out by themselves, or should battery researchers be helping with this effort to see if we can find a solution? It seems to me that the answer has to be the latter, but I fear that this will not be the case. The chemistry is considered too "un-sexy" (for want of a better word). Try presenting a paper on this at the Electrochemical Society meeting and you will asked to present on a Saturday morning (after the conference has ended!). To be fair there has recently been government support for these technologies for trying to commercialize them; but I don't see anything happening at the research stage.


The story of the lead-acid is far from unique. The few (very few) folks who continue to work on the Ni-MH system talk about the use of carbon fiber instead of nickel plaques to decrease the weight and cost of the battery and increase its specific energy. The person working on capacitors was telling me that he had ideas for increasing the energy by the factor of 2 (which, as it turns out, could be huge for a hybrid). There are companies working on Ni-Zn batteries that think they can do something better than Li-ion in some applications. But look at research in the US on batteries and there is pretty much zero effort in these areas. None of these ideas may pan out, but the question remains: should battery researchers be looking at these issues along with companies or should we all focus on one system (the lithium system)?


Part of the problem is the amount of funding that is available for battery research. If there was unlimited funding available, all these problems will be looked at. But with funding being tight, one needs to focus on a few problems and not spread one-selves too thin. Another problem is the community. As in any other area, there is a bit of jumping on the bandwagon that happens. Its tough being the only guy doing something, especially when no one cares for what you do.


At LBNL I wear two hats: one as a researcher looking at mathematically modeling batteries and another as the technical manager of the Batteries or Advanced Transportation Technologies (BATT) program. In my latter role, I have a hand at picking the kind of systems we work on. And I know exactly why we have picked to focus on the lithium battery exclusively. But the advances in these less "sexy" fields makes we wonder if this strategy is right. Weigh in with your views.


Venkat